Choosing Between International and Domestic Surrogacy: A Comprehensive Guide for American Intended Parents

When embarking on the journey of surrogacy to build your family, one crucial decision American intended parents face is choosing between international and domestic surrogacy. This decision holds profound implications, impacting various aspects of the surrogacy process. To navigate this choice effectively, it’s essential to consider several key factors. While both options offer the same outcome of having a child, there are significant differences between the two that individuals and couples must consider. In this article, we will explore the various aspects of international and domestic surrogacy, including the legal, financial, and ethical considerations, to help individuals make an informed decision when choosing between the two options.

With advancements in technology and increasing acceptance of non-traditional family structures, surrogacy has become a widely recognized option for building a family. However, as the demand for surrogacy grows, so does the debate between choosing international or domestic surrogacy.
 

A comparison between Domestic Surrogacy and International Surrogacy

When considering surrogacy as an option for building a family, it is essential to understand the differences between domestic surrogacy and international surrogacy.

International surrogacy involves seeking a surrogate mother in a foreign country, while domestic surrogacy involves finding a surrogate within one’s own country.

One significant factor to consider is the cost, as international surrogacy can be less costly but also consider additional expenses such as travel, accommodation, and legal fees.

Additionally, each country has its own set of laws and regulations regarding surrogacy, which can vary widely.

Some countries may have more comprehensive legal frameworks and established processes, while others may have limited regulations or legal uncertainties. It is crucial for intended parents to thoroughly research and understand the laws of the chosen international surrogacy country to ensure a smooth and legally secure process.

However, domestic surrogacy offers the advantage of being able to navigate the legal system with more familiarity and potentially easier access to medical and support services.

Ultimately, the decision between international and domestic surrogacy should be based on personal circumstances, preferences, and thorough consideration of the associated costs and legal complexities.

 Surrogacy Cost Considerations

Surrogacy Cost often plays a pivotal role in the decision-making process. Opting for international surrogacy may seem financially attractive, but it comes with potential extra costs like travel, accommodation, visa, and work loss costs. Sometimes you also need to consider the additional legal fees that you need to pay to bring your baby back to your country.

The reduced cost does not mean reduced quality of services.  Matter of fact, some surrogacy countries offer the same customer-centric approach and quality services as US-based surrogacy agencies.

Medical Standards

Completing the surrogacy process in the U.S. offers a distinct advantage in terms of adhering to the rigorous standards set by the American Society for Reproductive Medicine. This regulatory framework ensures that medical processes prioritize safety, ethics, and effectiveness.

In contrast, international surrogacy may involve uncertainties in medical practices and necessitate additional steps for procedures like embryo transfer. However, it is good that you choose the fertility clinic with the discussion on their medical protocol and success rate. Most of the international surrogacy countries do have rigorous medical protocols as they deal with international intended parents so they need to work on the line of international standards and quality protocols.

Screening of the surrogate Mother

The health and background screening of surrogates play a crucial role in ensuring a smooth surrogacy journey.  US-based surrogacy professionals meticulously assess surrogate candidates, considering physical and mental health, and criminal backgrounds, and ensuring their voluntary participation.

In international surrogacy, however, the selection criteria for surrogate mothers as not as descriptive and exhaustive.  However, it does not mean that the local surrogacy agencies are careless, they do follow all protocols there for surrogate mothers, but it might not be as deep as in the US.  It is good that you discuss with your international surrogacy agency about the screening selection process of low-cost international surrogate mothers.

Communication Challenges

When it comes to surrogacy, having robust and transparent communication is a must.  Whether you choose domestic surrogacy or international surrogacy, clear, transparent communication is important.

If you are working in long distance surrogacy agency, you need to check if your local agency has good communication patterns.  How quickly they are available to answer you and do you feel that your questions were well answered?

Differences in technology availability, time zones, and potential language barriers can hinder effective communication between intended parents and surrogates. This lack of instant contact may pose difficulties in addressing urgent issues promptly.

Legal Landscape

Surrogacy laws in the U.S., while varying by state, are well-regulated, providing a stable legal foundation for the process.

In contrast, international surrogacy faces a myriad of legal challenges, including restrictions in foreign countries and the absence of global regulations. This legal uncertainty poses a substantial risk for intended parents pursuing surrogacy abroad. Understanding your country’s surrogacy laws and surrogacy country laws is important to choosing the country that offers a safe and legal environment.

Comparative Table: International vs. Domestic Surrogacy

Aspect	Domestic Surrogacy	International Surrogacy
Surrogacy Process	– Mutual Decision-Making: In the U.S., finding a surrogate involves mutual consent, fostering collaborative and informed decision-making. – Legal Framework: Well-established surrogacy laws and standards, ensuring a regulated and familiar process. – Parental Involvement: Intended parents actively participate in the surrogacy journey, ensuring a transparent and supportive experience.	– Varied Legal Landscapes: Surrogacy laws and standards vary across countries, introducing complexities and potential uncertainties. – Limited Involvement: Distance may hinder active participation, requiring trust in the surrogacy professional’s ethical and legal practices.
Cost Considerations	– Transparent Expenses: While surrogacy in the U.S. can be costly, expenses correlate with the services offered, ensuring a comprehensive and secure process.	– Cost Attraction: Often perceived as more cost-effective, international surrogacy may involve reduced expenses.
Medical Standards	– Stringent Regulations: Adherence to the rigorous standards set by the American Society for Reproductive Medicine ensures safe and ethical medical practices.	– Variable Medical Practices: Varying standards and potential lack of medical advances raise uncertainties, necessitating additional precautions.
Screening	– Thorough Candidate Assessment: Conduct extensive screening, considering physical and mental health, criminal backgrounds, and voluntariness.	– Potential Shortcomings: Screening in international surrogacy may be less thorough due to resource constraints, posing potential risks to intended parents.
Communication Challenges	– Technological Facilitation: Advanced communication technologies ease long-distance communication, fostering a close connection between intended parents and surrogates.	– Logistical Hurdles: Challenges include potential technology disparities, time zone differences, and language barriers, hindering instant and effective communication.
Legal Landscape	– Well-Regulated Environment: Surrogacy laws in the U.S., though varying by state, offer a stable legal foundation for a secure surrogacy journey.	– Varied Legal Challenges: Foreign restrictions and the absence of global regulations introduce legal uncertainties, posing potential risks for intended parents.

Pros and cons of Domestic Surrogacy and International Surrogacy

When considering the pros and cons of domestic surrogacy and international surrogacy, there are several factors to take into account.

One advantage of domestic surrogacy is the familiarity with the legal system and regulations within one’s own country. This can provide a sense of security and ease in navigating the surrogacy process.

Additionally, communication and coordination may be more convenient and accessible when working with a surrogate in the same country.

On the other hand, international surrogacy offers a wider range of options in terms of available surrogate mothers and potential matches. Intended parents may have more flexibility in selecting a surrogate who aligns with their preferences and criteria.

International surrogacy also allows access to surrogacy-friendly countries that may have well-established surrogacy programs and supportive legal frameworks.

However, it is important to consider that international surrogacy costs will be half of what you pay in a typical US surrogacy program.  There might be additional costs involved, including travel expenses, accommodation, and legal fees. Language barriers and cultural differences may also present additional complexities in the surrogacy journey.

In a nutshell, domestic surrogacy can be familiar and easy logistically but higher surrogacy costs in the US make it out of reach for many intended parents.  For these IPs, international surrogacy countries like Mexico, Colombia, Argentina, Georgia, and Ukraine offer legal and affordable surrogacy alternatives.

Factors to consider when choosing international surrogacy.

When considering international surrogacy, there are several important factors to take into consideration.

• Firstly, it is crucial to thoroughly research and understand the legalities and regulations surrounding international surrogacy in both the intended parent’s home country and the chosen international surrogacy destination.
• Each country may have different laws and requirements, including eligibility criteria for intended parents and the rights and responsibilities of all parties involved.
• Additionally, the international surrogacy cost should be carefully considered, as it may vary significantly depending on the chosen country and the specific services and arrangements provided. It is essential to assess the financial implications and budget accordingly, taking into account not just the surrogate’s compensation, but also legal fees, medical expenses, travel costs, and any additional services required.
• Another factor to consider is the availability and quality of medical and healthcare facilities in the chosen international surrogacy country.
• Ensuring that the medical infrastructure is reputable and meets the necessary standards is crucial for the well-being and safety of both the surrogate mother and the intended child.
• Finally, it is important to evaluate the cultural, language, and logistical challenges that may arise when engaging in international surrogacy.
• Cultural differences and potential language barriers can impact communication and understanding between the intended parents and the surrogate mother.
• Additionally, the distance and travel logistics involved in international surrogacy require careful planning and consideration.

Taking all of these factors into account can help intended parents make an informed decision when choosing international surrogacy as a viable option for building their family.

International Surrogacy Cost Breakdown And Budgeting.

International Surrogacy can be a complex process, both emotionally and financially. Understanding the cost breakdown and effectively budgeting for international surrogacy is crucial for intended parents.

The cost of international surrogacy can vary greatly depending on the chosen country and the specific services required. It typically includes various components such as agency fees, legal fees, medical expenses, surrogate compensation, travel costs, and insurance.

It is important to thoroughly research and compare the costs associated with different international surrogacy countries to make an informed decision. Creating a detailed budget and seeking professional advice can help intended parents navigate the financial aspects of international surrogacy and ensure they are prepared for all expenses involved.

By carefully considering the cost breakdown and budgeting, intended parents can embark on their surrogacy journey with a clear understanding of the financial commitments involved.

International surrogacy costs worldwide

 Cheapest countries for surrogacy:

Country	Regulation & Organization	Who are allowed to participate	Surrogacy Cost	Legal Assurance
Colombia	Altruistic	Singles, gay couples, hetero couples	Affordable $70,000	Reliable
Mexico	Altruistic	Singles, gay couples, hetero couples	Affordable $70,000 to $80,000	Reliable
USA	Commercial	Singles, gay couples, hetero couples	Costly $150,000+	Strong
Ukraine	Commercial	Hetero couples	Affordable $60,000	Strong
Georgia	Commercial	Hetero couples	Affordable $60,000	Strong
Greece	Altruistic	Hetero couples and single women	Affordable $80,000	Strong

Top Countries For International Surrogacy Options.

When exploring international surrogacy options, it is essential to consider the countries known for their favorable surrogacy laws and regulations.

Some of the top countries for international surrogacy include Georiga, Ukraine,  Mexico, Colombia, Armenia and Argentina. 

These countries have established legal frameworks that protect the rights of intended parents and ensure a smooth and secure surrogacy process.

Additionally, they offer high-quality medical facilities and experienced professionals who specialize in assisted reproductive technology. It is important to research each country’s specific regulations, cultural practices, and requirements to determine the best fit for your surrogacy journey.

Consulting with a reputable surrogacy agency or legal professional can provide valuable guidance and support in navigating the international surrogacy landscape.

 Table with information on countries and their surrogacy laws:

Country	Commercial Surrogacy	Altruistic Surrogacy	Surrogacy Status
Australia	Prohibited	Allowed	Altruistic surrogacy is legal in all jurisdictions. Commercial surrogacy is a criminal offense.
Canada	Banned	Allowed	Only altruistic surrogacy is permitted. Compensation for gestational carriers is limited to approved expenses.
Colombia	Uncertain	Allowed	There are no clear rules, but altruistic surrogacy is performed and well tolerated.
Greece	Banned	Allowed	Heterosexual couples, and single females are allowed.
India	Prohibited	Allowed	Altruistic surrogacy is permitted for certain couples based on medical and age criteria.
Israel	Allowed	Allowed	Gestational surrogacy is legal under the Embryo Carrying Agreements Law.
Kenya	N/A	N/A	No legal regulations/laws for surrogacy in Kenya.
Mexico	Allowed	N/A	Surrogacy, along with ovum and sperm donation, has been legal since 1992.
New Zealand	N/A	Allowed	Altruistic surrogacy is legal.
Thailand	Banned	N/A	Commercial surrogacy is criminalized under the Medical Council Act.
Ukraine	Allowed	Allowed	Surrogacy and egg/sperm donation are legal and supported by liberal laws.
United Kingdom	N/A	Allowed	Surrogacy laws vary across different states/territories in the UK.
United States	Varies by state	Allowed	Surrogacy laws vary by state, some are surrogacy-friendly, while others restrict or penalize commercial surrogacy.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the decision between international and domestic surrogacy is a complex and deeply personal one. It is important to carefully consider all factors, including legal and cultural differences, before making a decision.

Ultimately, the most important thing is to work with a reputable and experienced surrogacy agency that prioritizes the well-being of all parties involved. Whether choosing international or domestic surrogacy, the end goal is the same: to create a loving and fulfilling family. With proper research and guidance, the process can be a successful and rewarding journey for all involved.

If you’d like to learn more about IVF, Egg Donation, or surrogacy services globally, check out the rest of our website at Complete Surrogacy. We offer legally secure and affordable surrogacy consulting services for FREE.

Our team has over 13 years of experience facilitating surrogacy arrangements, egg donation, and serving as an advocacy resource for infertile couples and LGBTQ individuals seeking to build families.

Our founder and chief surrogacy consultant, Neelam Chhagani, passionately helps couples struggling with fertility challenges. Since starting our surrogacy consulting agency in 2013, we’ve helped welcome over 500 babies for intended parents nationwide.

Our team includes experts from diverse backgrounds with leading reproductive attorneys, professionally trained top fertility doctors, former surrogacy case managers, experienced and kind surrogate mother and egg donor coordinators, mental health professionals specializing in infertility counseling, and a logistic support team to assist you in your chosen surrogacy country.

For more resources on IVF and Surrogacy, browse our other web page- IVF Conceptions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is international surrogacy more affordable for American intended parents? 

Yes, international surrogacy is cost-effective.  In the USA, the typical surrogacy cost is between $150,000 to $200,000, however, international surrogacy costs start at $50,000.  The actual cost depends on the country and services you choose.

What legal challenges do American intended parents face in international surrogacy? 

Legal challenges in international surrogacy include varying regulations in foreign countries, restrictions for foreigners, and the absence of global surrogacy regulations. This legal uncertainty poses significant risks and complicates the surrogacy process.

What are the main factors to consider when deciding between international and domestic surrogacy?

When deciding between international and domestic surrogacy, there are several main factors to consider.

• Firstly, cost is a significant consideration as international surrogacy can be more expensive due to travel, legal, and logistical expenses.
• Secondly, legal considerations differ between countries, so it’s crucial to understand the legal framework and ensure the process is legally binding and protected.
• Additionally, cultural and language barriers may exist in international surrogacy, impacting communication and the overall experience.
• Lastly, ethical concerns regarding exploitation and regulation should be thoroughly researched and taken into account during the decision-making process.
• Overall, these factors should be carefully weighed to make an informed decision between international and domestic surrogacy.

How does the cost of international surrogacy compare to domestic surrogacy?

The cost of international surrogacy is typically higher than domestic surrogacy. International surrogacy involves additional expenses such as travel, accommodation, legal fees, and translation services. In some cases, intended parents may also need to pay for the surrogate’s medical expenses, insurance, and compensation, all of which can vary significantly depending on the country. Additionally, international surrogacy often requires more complex legal arrangements and can be subject to changing laws and regulations, adding to the overall cost. Domestic surrogacy, on the other hand, typically involves fewer logistical challenges and may have more predictable costs, although this can still vary depending on the specific circumstances and location.

Are there any cultural or language barriers that may arise in international surrogacy arrangements?

Yes, cultural and language barriers can arise in international surrogacy arrangements. These barriers can include differences in beliefs, values, and customs between the intended parents and the surrogate mother.

Additionally, language barriers can make communication and understanding more difficult, leading to misunderstandings and potential conflicts. It is essential for all parties involved to have open and clear communication, as well as to engage in cultural sensitivity and awareness to navigate these potential barriers successfully.

What are the potential advantages and disadvantages of choosing a domestic surrogacy agency versus an international one?

Choosing a domestic surrogacy agency can have advantages such as easier communication, familiarity with local laws and regulations, and access to local resources and support networks.

However, it may come with higher costs, limited surrogate options, and longer wait times due to higher demand.

On the other hand, opting for an international surrogacy agency can offer a wider pool of potential surrogates, potentially lower costs, and faster matching processes.

However, it may be challenging to navigate different legal systems and cultural differences, and there may be language barriers and travel expenses involved.

About The Author